I was actually disappointed. Visually it’s a stunning film, but plot-wise I wanted more. It ended up being your standard hero-quest narrative with the Hatter as ObiWan Kenobi and Alice as a particularly whiny Like. (“But I don’t WANNA be a champion!!!!”)
As for being “Alice” – it was like they took all the elements of the story, tossed them all into a big bag, pulled them out at random, and did origami with them. I just didn’t think it hung together as a story.
It’s great-looking, the design is fabulous and very interesting, and the actors do really well with the material they were given, but I was left feeling a bit hollow. Style over substance I’m afraid.
I was actually more impressed with the re-imagining of the Syfy channel’s ‘Alice’ – done by some of the same team that did ‘Tin Man’ which was a reimagining of The Wizard of Oz. It was weird and definitely scifi but had all the plot elements and the characters were definitely based on the original but with a spin all their own.