Ok so I thought I would share this in case others were dealing with a similar issue.
Molly is no longer a baby so I stopped giving her alfalfa hay around a month ago. We tried timothy hay, but she would not eat it. So we tried orchard grass hay, and she took to that much better. However, she wasn’t eating as much of it as she used to eat the alfalfa, and I was worried she wans’t getting enough.
I cut back on the pellets, but even still she was hardly touching the hay (even tho she immediately showed a preference for the orchard over timothy previously) and would gobble up the pellets like she was starving!
So this is what I tried: I took a toilet paper roll that was in her cage that she never plays with, and stuffed it full of hay. The result: she immediatley starts nibbling at the hay and trying to get it out! I think making getting the hay into a game has worked to encourage her to eat it because I notice that she eats a lot more from the pile of hay I leave in her cage as well! This is great I’m happy it worked!! 