I really feel it is more the fault of the manufacturers of these treats than it is the average consumer (although I do believe it is buyer beware). That is one of the main reasons that I will not feed Kaytee Timothy to my bunny- I chose another brand. I feel that Kaytee responded to market demand withh this pellet- but all of their other rabbit products (excluding hay) are basically junk food and either not healthy or even worse- not even appropriate to feed a bunny. Why do they make these products then? It is all about money.
Healthy treats are out there- we just have to wade through all the garbage to get to them. I have at least 6 containers of treats that I have found are bunny appropriate- Oxbow Papaya tablets, Oxbow Critter berries, Oxbow Critter Carrots (carrot pellets that have sugar), dehydrated fruit that I made (Cotton likes blueberries), Orchard Sweets Apple treats (100% apple pellets) and some 100% timothy hay pellets that my husbands co-worker gave to him (her guinea pig would not eat them). She only gets 2 treats that have fruit(sugar) per day and not at the same time- and I scatter the hay pellets and carrot pellets throughout her enclosure so she has to find them.
I also have some the the berry Smaks treats but I went and broke each heart into about 3 pieces and she only occasionally get a piece.
It is funny because the blueberries that I dehydrated in our dehydrator look alot like bunny poos. Cotton was willing to try blueberries- but she would not try the strawberries. Cotton is really, really picky….the only treat the she ate the first time offered was the Oxbow Papaya and Oxbow Critter Berries- which leads me to believe she can smell the natural sugar in them. She is attracted to the smell of sweet stuff- but she will never try it. She will sniff my glass of Mountain Dew- but will never try to lick it, she has sniffed fruit popsicles- but has never tried to lick one. I guess I should be happy that my bunny does not beg and try to steal snacks when we are watching TV. I have seen my husband offer her a piece of cracker and she is not interested at all- I think that is the only reason he offered her any.