Alfalfa tastes really good and I don’t think many rabbits would ever choose something else if alfalfa is available, haha. My Wick barely ate his Timothy pellets when we first transitioned, but eventually he got there. He was never on alfalfa hay (health reasons), but I imagine the same difficulty would have existed. I haven’t read of many rabbits who willingly prefer something else to alfalfa.
When it comes to hay, you don’t need to worry about a slow transition from one to the other. What will probably best facilitate eating non-alfalfa hay is not having it present anymore. Rabbits are selective foragers, so they will always seek the best strands first. Mixing in alfalfa means those will go first and the rest will be ignored. You can always have a stash for the first day or two in case there is no hay eating, but I think eliminating the alfalfa hay altogether would reap the best results.
I’m curious what others think based on personal experiences!
The answers provided in this discussion are for general guideline purposes only. The information is not intended to diagnose or treat your pet. Seek the advice of your veterinarian or a qualified behaviorist.