So, disclaimer is that I have not successfully bonded a trio. 🙁 I have 2 failed trio attempts and one failed quad, but all attempts involved the same two girls that were just not having it. So take my advice with a grain of salt! But I have bonded many pairs successfully lol
How big is the bonding area? I’ve always found that litter boxes can cause issues, and sometimes treats can make the buns overly excited, so I usually don’t have any food down for the short initial dates. I also have always had better luck with large spaces, and Margo DiMello of the San Diego HRS always uses HUGE spaces to bond trios and groups (think like 3 x-pens linked up). The idea is that if one bun nips the other, if there is no space to move away from the other it can escalate to a fight because there is no way for them to de-escalate things themselves. So if you are using very small spaces, you might consider trying a larger space. It also seems like people who bond in small spaces often have issues when trying to transition to larger spaces later on.
Have you tried any stressing with them? With tougher bonds I have had good luck with doing a short car ride together first, followed by a short date in a large space.
I think the petting you’ve been doing to calm them is good, you can do more petting when they request grooming to help boost some positive feelings between them.
Overall I think the main advice is to remove the food for now, keep working with them, and keep preventing fights as you have been. If you feel things are getting worse or stagnating, experiment with the size of the space and maybe try adding a car ride before.
.
.
.
The answers provided in this discussion are for general guideline purposes only. The information is not intended to diagnose or treat your pet. Seek the advice of your veterinarian or a qualified behaviorist.