Girl buns, even when spayed, can be still territorial over their space. It sounds silly for her to be territorial with one cat and not the other, but it can happen.vits really hard to say what would be causing it specifically, aside from maybe just being scared of her and lashing out out of fear.
I know minimizing her space sounds mean, but when you get another pet and you’re trying to make them all happy, sometimes you do what you have to do. That being said, can you give her a designated bunny room or have her in an xpen setup while she’s near the cats that way the one she’s bullying can be safe?
Why would you rehome your bunny when you’ve had her the longest out of them, it doesn’t seem very fair to her. Not trying to sound rude, I’m just honestly wondering why the cats would take precedent. If I ever got a second pet that had issues with my boys, the second pet would be gone in a heartbeat. I couldn’t see doing that to a pet that’s been with me for so long. That’s basically like you couldn’t adjust to these new creatures, so they can stay and you can’t. With bunnies so many things can set them off, even if they were previously familiar with it. My boys were raised around 2 dogs at the breeder. 2 years later we moved into a shared house that has 3 pugs and my boy Az is absolutely terrified of even the smell of them to the point where I have to wash my hands if I’ve touched one. Bunnies are inherently prey animals and cats are predators, and maybe he can sense that in the one she’s bullying. It’s hard to say.