Sierra Valley Hay is excellent. I currently buy from my local rescue, but I used to get from them.

Ruling out a dental issue or some other medical problem (are they pooping and eating veggies, etc. normally?) is the first step. But since you have two, I’m guessing it’s something else.

Mine don’t eat quite as much hay during the day. They mostly eat hay at night. They also seem to eat more when I top it up with small amounts frequently, so it’s always fresh. They also seem to like it more out of their box than their hay rack, so I use both.

Since they aren’t finishing their pellets, you might be overfeeding pellets, which would also explain not eating very much hay. How much pellets do they get, and how big are your bunnies?

If you have found your bunnies prefer hay from the local source, for sure continue with that. What type of hay is it? You might try using different types of hay or mixing a few to encourage munching and see what they like best. For adult bunnies you can try timothy, meadow, orchard, or oat.
If they prefer eating from their boxes, you might try filling the boxes with small amounts frequently, as DanaNM said. Something about sitting in their own poop makes bunnies hungry.
You can also try putting hay in different types of toys, cardboard boxes, etc, to encourage munching.

Hi Bumpkin, I am going through having this very same issue with my BunBun. I have been wanting to switch her over to Small Pet Select from different hay company that she loves but due to high cost, crushed product, slow shipping speeds and extremely inconsistent quality, especially for the price. I tried SPS in December and my gal would hardly look at it. So I immediately went back to the other company. I have recently been seeing an extreme steady decline in quality of my orders, though from the only hay BunBun will eat, so I just tried an order again with SPS. This time I didn’t have any of the other hay left (at least none worth giving her) so she was extremely hungry and ate it sporadically but definitely not enough for me to not be concerned about her intake. I always order Second Cut Timothy because that seems to be the one she most desires. I just really wish she would eat the SPS bcz the other company is becoming an extreme monetary risk and I cannot afford to lose $30 a month for hay that is only worth sticking in her litter box as filler. Then to also just have to try and order more and pray I get a good batch. My Bun has me over a barrel.

Getting a bale is def the most economical and usually the freshest!

But, if that’t not an option for you, and you do want to try ordering, I do highly recommend Sierra Valley Hay (esp if you’re on the west coast). My buns always loved every batch and would eat tons. They have different cuts of timothy and other varieties (orchard, oat, etc).

Oxbow also has 50lb boxes from Dr. Fosters and Smith. I went through them before Sierra. Sierra was better quality, but if you’re on the East coast, shipping is more from Sierra.

Just to second what everyone else said–my Bun had the same issue, but with Oxbow hay and what has helped me the most is putting out small amounts of hay more frequently. It seems like my rabbit feels it is “fresher” that way and also the more frequent feedings sort of re-interests him in the hay again as opposed to one big amount sitting there all day. Good luck!

If anyone is based in the uk, I would 100% recommend the Timothy hay in Timothyhay.co.uk/
I have 2 very picky eaters, who would not touch anything apart from their readigrass- however since the grass did not do as much for their teeth, we wanted to switch hays. We gave this Timothy hay and they absolutely loved it, choosing it over their readigrass (which they happily and enthusiastically ate for years). This was quite a suprise cause they wouldnt eat other brands of timothy hay like Oxbow. This hay is also cheaper and they have so many 5 star reviews, so definitely worth a try.