You can get American Pet Diner Tomothy Gold, which is a second cutting, soft Timothy hay. It comes in the small 10 oz bags, and you can get it in 5 lb. bags too. Binky Bunny store has the small bags, but I’m not sure about the large bags. I get the 5 lb. bags from http://www.drsfostersmith.com.
I also like Zupreem Timothy hay. It is not stated what type of Timothy it is, but it has always been a soft, fresh hay that my bunnies really like. They don’t have that at Drs. Foster & Smith, but I get it from http://www.petfooddirect.com. It’s also available at other online retailers. Even though some of the pet supply stores sell Zupreem pellets, none of them carry the hay, so I have to order it..
I was not happy with the last 2 or 3 bags of Oxbow Timothy, and my bunnies didn’t like it much either. It seemed dry and with mostly hard stalks. I’m sure that’s a lot of fiber, and probably good for their teeth too, but if your rabbits don’t like it and won’t eat much of it, then they’re not getting much fiber anyway. I do still buy Oxbow orchard grass, botanical hay and organic meadow hay, but for Timothy hay, I’m using APD Timothy Gold and the Zupreem.
I do use Oxbow pellets, and those have always been good quality.