Mimzy is a characteristic non-hay eater…meaning if he can avoid it, he won’t eat it, but if it’s the only thing there, it goes down. But he is hard to please in this regard in any case. (He would have to be the one that has to have perfect hay. And he’s a pellet muncher to the extremes.)
I just ordered some of the botanical from Fosters&Smith. It’s taking it’s time getting here, but I will report back on Mr. Picky once he’s tried it. Someone in my area sells brome hay, I may also try a bale of that sometime soon.
Mimzy has had fresh hayseed from the yard, so I wonder if his pickiness has to do with not having that during the winter? Quantum, does your rabbit tend to go for fresh things like veggies? And location is sometimes key too. You saw she was more interested when it was in her litterbox? (Mine used to like that.) I’ve also been told here that sometimes you have to hand feed a small quantity throughout the day as frequently as possible to get them used to eating hay. (The extra attention they receive from you is the perk.)