substitute for Valley Organic Orchard hay??

Forum

OUR FORUM IS UP BUT WE ARE STILL IN THE MIDDLE OF UPDATING AND FIXING THINGS. SOME THINGS WILL LOOK WEIRD AND/OR NOT BE CORRECT. YOUR PATIENCE IS APPRECIATED. We are not fully ready to answer questions in a timely manner as we are not officially open, but we will do our best.

You may have received a 2-factor authentication (2FA) email from us on 4/21/2020. That was from us, but was premature as the login was not working at that time.

BUNNY 911 – If your rabbit hasn’t eaten or pooped in 12-24 hours, call a vet immediately! Don’t have a vet? Check out VET RESOURCES

The subject of intentional breeding or meat rabbits is prohibited. The answers provided on this board are for general guideline purposes only. The information is not intended to diagnose or treat your pet. It is your responsibility to assess the information being given and seek professional advice/second opinion from your veterinarian and/or qualified behaviorist.

What are we about? Please read about our Forum Culture and check out the Rules.

BUNNY 911 – If your rabbit hasn’t eaten or pooped in 12-24 hours, call a vet immediately! Don’t have a vet? Check out VET RESOURCES

BINKYBUNNY FORUMS

This topic has 13sd replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 5 months ago by TBpony414.

Viewing 13 reply threads

Author

Messages
- 10/26/2011 at 10:10 AM
  Meg
  Participant
  560 posts
  Hey all! I’ve got two adorable but very picky bunnies who got addicted to the Valley Organic orchard hay that’s been discontinued… after ordering the 25-lb box before they went out of business, we’re finally on the last few days’ worth, and I’m starting to panic! I ordered a whole bunch of bales of the BB orchard hay, which so many other bunnies love, but mine won’t even *touch* it!
  
  Has anyone else found a source of nice leafy orchard hay similar to Valley Organic? I think part of its allure for my bunnies might be that it has so many nice dried leaves, flowers, and other special treats in there. They go nuts over even just the regular grass blades, though. They love it so much, I’d do anything to be able to give them more hay like this! (They will eat oat hay (I’ve tried every other healthy kind: Timothy Blue Blend, Oxbow Botanical, etc, and nothing else works), but since the BB kind has been discontinued for the season, we can only get the Oxbow kind and I’d like them to have something fresher in addition.)
  
  Has anyone had any luck with another farm-sourced orchard hay?
- 10/26/2011 at 10:55 AM
  AbbyGirl
  Participant
  921 posts
  My first Flemmie was very picky about his hay and he liked Oxbow’s Orchard grass. It was nice soft hay.
- 10/26/2011 at 11:02 AM
  Stickerbunny
  Participant
  4128 posts
  No, but if you find something fresher than oxbow let me know – mine looove orchard grass hay and I feed oxbow at the moment, but they’d like something fresher I am sure. The farms around here don’t really sell hay beyond alfalfa.
- 10/26/2011 at 6:36 PM
  equalsign
  Participant
  220 posts
  You could try American Pet Diner hay. Never tried it myself, but they seem to be positioning themselves to take on Oxbow.
  
  Many people swear by Farmer Dave’s Hay, but he doesn’t seem to have orchard grass at the moment.
  
  You can get a 50 lb box of Oxbow orchard grass hay from Doctors Foster and Smith for 75 with free shipping. Just FYI.
  
  Mine is from the Bunny Bunch, a shelter in Montclair, CA. Once I run out I’ll be getting some from Doctors Foster and Smith. I cannot speak for how fresh it is, as I have no standard for comparison. They do ship.
- 10/26/2011 at 7:18 PM
  LoveChaCha
  Participant
  6634 posts
  I had the same problem. My picky bunny really loved Valley Organic.
  
  I suggest American Pet Diner Orchard. She loves it!
- 10/26/2011 at 9:46 PM
  TBpony414
  Participant
  166 posts
  My unbelievably picky bunny was also in love with Valley Organic’s hay. When we ran out he started gobbling up the mature oat hay BB sells, except soon after that was discontinued and it won’t be back until sometime next year. The only acceptable substitute I’ve been able to find is Oxbow’s Organic Meadow Grass. I asked a local pet store to special order me a bag (free shipping) so I could try it. Turns out they ordered a case of it and put the other bags on the shelves to see if other customers would buy it. Apparently it was a hit so now it’s usually on the shelves! I’ve tried other brands of orchard grass, blue grass, etc. hays but Willy just refuses to touch them. The Oxbow organic meadow grass has been a success for several months now and since our bunnies have similar hay preferences, I bet yours may like it too!
- 10/27/2011 at 6:50 AM
  Meg
  Participant
  560 posts
  Wow, thank you so much! This is so helpful!! I’m going to try the Oxbow organic meadow grass and the American Pet Diner orchard as well! I really appreciate it.
  
  I found a couple sites for fresh hay — don’t know if anyone’s tried them:
  
  http://www.barbibrownsbunnies.com
  http://www.sierravalleyhay.com
  http://www.sweetmeadowfarm.com
  
  Thanks again!!
- 11/03/2011 at 2:32 PM
  equalsign
  Participant
  220 posts
  Make sure you let us know if they’re good!
- 11/04/2011 at 10:04 AM
  Meg
  Participant
  560 posts
  Definitely! So far we’ve tried the Oxbow organic meadow hay, which the bunnies like (though not quite as much as they did the Valley Organic kind). Thanks for the tip on that! We’ve also tried Sweet Meadow, which to me smells delicious, but the bunnies would probably rank that as #3 (behind Valley Organic and Oxbow). They will eat it some, though. I’m also going to try Sierra Valley, so I’ll let you know how that goes. For now I’m just grateful that they’ll eat the Oxbow, even if it’s not farm-fresh.
  
  Thanks!
- 11/04/2011 at 10:24 AM
  BinkyBunny
  Moderator
  8776 posts
  If your bunny doesn’t like the BB Orchard, then they are not going to like Barbie Browns because we have the same bales. .
- 11/04/2011 at 10:34 AM
  Meg
  Participant
  560 posts
  Oh, good to know! Thanks.
- 11/04/2011 at 9:12 PM
  TBpony414
  Participant
  166 posts
  Meg, please update after you get your Sierra Valley order! Did you just order orchard grass from Sweet Meadow, or other hays as well? I’m happy to hear your bunnies will eat the Oxbow meadow hay. In my (human) opinion, meadow is nowhere near as fresh or exciting as V.O. hay. We had a really rough and long transition period and I’m at the point where I don’t really care if my bunny likes the hay – just as long as he eats it!!! I give Willy 6+ handfuls of hay throughout the day to keep him somewhat entertained. When I make a pile, within an hour he completely loses interest and refuses to eat. Then he turns into a gassy, bloated, angry bunny who needs lots of simethicone, tummy rubs and critical care. What is the male version of a picky diva??
  
  BB, I don’t think I ever emailed you back about the Oxbow Oat hay. Willy won’t eat it – the bags I’ve gotten are all finely chopped up young oat, and he prefers your gorgeous, thick, long and crunchy mature oat. Sigh…
- 11/04/2011 at 9:46 PM
  Meg
  Participant
  560 posts
  OK, I’ll be sure to let you know! I did just order the meadow/orchard from Sweet Meadow… they sent a bag of timothy as well but I really doubt my bunnies will deign to try it! But I’ll experiment and keep you posted. Have you tried the Oxbow oat hay for Willy? I agree, the BB mature kind was better, but my bunnies will eat the Oxbow kind too. (It’s similar to the BB mature oat.) I like having at least 2 for variety.
- 11/04/2011 at 10:10 PM
  TBpony414
  Participant
  166 posts
  Thanks I have 3 or 4 bags of the Oxbow oat and he rates it two big floppy ears down. I’m currently mixing it in with the meadow grass and Willy is kinda sorta nibbling at it, but not at all tearing open boxes and leaping off the back of the couch to get to it like he did with BB’s mature oat. The barn I board my horse at has some sort of grass hay as well as alfalfa but Willy won’t touch either of those. Oh well, gotta love him!
Author

Messages